Are early Black Friday deals real?
Updated November 16, 2026, with weekly Fake Deal Index figures through the week of November 16. First published October 23, 2026.
Black Friday has not been a single day for years. “Early Black Friday” badges start appearing in early November, sometimes before, and by the week of Thanksgiving almost every product page carries some kind of offer language. The question for a shopper is whether those early deals are as good as the ones on the day itself.
Our data suggested, in October, that they often are not. The November weeks we have now measured look the same way: they resemble ordinary weeks, not the October sale event.
What we have measured
For the Fake Deal Index we check a fresh sample of advertised deals every week and count how many are not meaningfully below the product’s usual price. Across 19 published weekly reports, that share has ranged from 8% to 27% and has averaged 19%. We also measured the October sale event, Prime Big Deal Days (October 6–7), once while it was live: 108 of 1,750 deals (6%) were not real discounts.
So in our sample, an ordinary week has carried roughly three times as many padded discounts as that event day. The November run-up has not broken the pattern:
| Week of | Deals scanned | Not meaningfully below usual price | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 26 | 1,687 | 307 | 18% |
| Nov 2 | 1,689 | 260 | 15% |
| Nov 9 | 1,711 | 305 | 18% |
| Nov 16 | 1,641 | 260 | 16% |
The week of November 16, in the days still left before Black Friday, came in at 16% — close to the 19-week average, and well above the 6% event-day reading. For comparison, the weekly report taken on October 5, the day before the October event when early event prices were already appearing, was 8%. The two weeks after that event were 13% and 15%. A badge in a run-up week is not the same evidence as a price on the event day.
Why the run-up looks like an ordinary week
We measure prices, not intentions, but the pattern fits a simple explanation. On the event days themselves, shoppers compare. Lists of real lows circulate, and a padded price gains little. In the weeks around an event, the promotional language is everywhere, and nothing about the words “early Black Friday” requires the price to be lower than usual.
The highest weeks in our sample make the same point. The three highest were August 3 (27%), August 10 (25%) and August 17 (23%), the peak of back-to-school promotion, when there is a seasonal reason to badge everything but no single event day that concentrates comparison shopping.
Where the risk is highest right now
In the week of November 16, pet supplies (55%, 49 of 89) and computers (43%, 56 of 131) had the largest share of advertised deals that were not meaningfully below usual price. Furniture (30%) and office supplies (24%) were also elevated. That last pair matters because they barely improved during the October event either (furniture 18%, office 25%, against 24.7% and 28.6% in the 15-week ordinary-week pool).
Computers, by contrast, fell from 33.6% in ordinary weeks to 4% during the October event. A mid-November computer badge is among the least reliable signals in this week’s data, even though the same category cleaned up on the October event days. The full category comparison is in which Black Friday deal categories to trust.
Three common shapes of an early “deal”
The list-price discount
The badge is measured against a manufacturer’s list price that the product has not sold at for months, if ever. The percentage can be large while the price is exactly where it always is. This is the most common pattern in computers.
The bump before the cut
The price rises for a while in October or early November, then returns to roughly its usual level with a badge. Against last week it is a real drop. Against the last three months it is nothing. Our comparison uses the usual price over 90 days, which is why a short bump does not fool it.
The deal that is only a deal on the day
Some products do get a genuine Black Friday price, but only on the event days. In the weeks before, the same listing may show a smaller badge on a price that is no lower than usual. Buying early locks in the ordinary price.
How to handle early deals without missing the good ones
- Treat an early badge as a reason to check, not to buy. Look at the product’s price history and see whether today’s price is actually below its usual level. Paste the link into worthitforyou, or open the free iPhone or Android app and scan the barcode.
- If an early price is near the lowest in the history we have, it is a real low. There is no rule that Black Friday will beat it, and stock on genuine lows can run out.
- If it is at the usual price, wait. In our data the October event days were far more honest than the weeks around them, and this November week still looks ordinary.
- Watch the weekly number. The Black Friday fake deal tracker will add the week of November 23 when that scan is published, and a frozen Black Friday report on November 28.
How these numbers are measured
Every week we take a fresh sample of advertised Amazon deals, about 1,500 to 1,750 of them, spread across 13 shopping categories so that no single category dominates. For each one we compare today’s price with the price that product has usually sold for over the previous 90 days, using our own price research. A deal counts as “not really a deal” (we call it busted) when today’s price is within 8% of that usual price or higher. In other words, the discount badge is there, but the price is not meaningfully lower than what the product normally costs.
That rule is deliberately generous to retailers. A product that is 9% below its usual price passes, even if its struck-through “was” price is wildly inflated. So the share you see is a floor, not a ceiling: the real number of misleading discounts is, if anything, higher. Each week’s report, its examples and a downloadable CSV are on the Fake Deal Index, and the full method is on our methodology page.
For a timetable that puts all of this together, see our week-by-week Black Friday 2026 plan.
BUY / WAIT / SKIP / FAIR come only from a product Check, never from a blog post.